avvo

Opening a Safe Deposit Box After Death in NY

safe deposit boxA family member can get a court order to open a deceased person's safe deposit box under SCPA 2003, usually within days. But the order only lets you look inside and take out three specific things. Everything else goes back in the box and stays there until an executor or administrator is appointed.

That distinction is the whole point of the section, and it is where most families are caught out.

Can I just open my parent's safe deposit box?

Almost certainly not, even if your name is on it.

Banks routinely deny access to surviving joint tenants of safe deposit boxes — including spouses and deputies — without a court order. That is not the bank being difficult. Once the bank knows a lessee has died, it has every reason to require a court's authority before anyone opens it.

Which is a problem, because the box often holds exactly what the family needs in the first week: the last will, a deed to a burial plot, or instructions about the decedent's remains.

It is also a problem in the other direction. Before the Surrogate's Court will let anyone file an Administration Petition alleging there was no will, it generally requires a search of all safe deposit boxes first. So the box has to be opened before the estate can even be started.

This is why we advise clients not to keep documents that will be needed immediately after death in a safe deposit box. A will in a box is a will behind a locked door and a court order.

What does SCPA 2003 actually allow?

Section 2003 of the Surrogate's Court Procedure Act exists to get at urgent documents quickly. It is not a route to collecting the assets.

The petition has to show two things: that a person, firm or corporation holds the decedent's papers, or that the decedent leased a safe deposit box from it; and that those papers or that box may contain a will, a deed to a burial plot, or an insurance policy payable to a named beneficiary.

If the court is satisfied, it issues an Order to Open Safe Deposit Box. The box is then opened, examined, inventoried and sealed again.

What can be taken out, and who gets it

Item found Where it goes
A paper appearing to be the will Delivered to the clerk of the Surrogate's Court
A deed to a burial plot To the person designated in the court's order
An insurance policy payable to a named beneficiary To that beneficiary
Everything else Inventoried, returned to the box, and held by the bank pending a further court order

Cash, jewellery, savings bonds, title documents, the lot — inventoried and put back. Nobody takes anything out until a fiduciary has been appointed.

How do I get the order?

  1. File the petition in the Surrogate's Court of the county where the decedent lived, with a death certificate. The court generally charges $20 for the petition and $6 per box.
  2. Receive the Order to Open Safe Deposit Box once the court has reviewed the petition and the fee is paid.
  3. Find the key. If nobody has it, this is where the time and the money go — the bank will have to drill the box, which is arranged at its convenience and billed to the estate.
  4. Make an appointment with a bank officer at the branch holding the box. Not any branch. The one where the box is.
  5. Attend with the order and the key. The box is opened in the officer's presence and the contents are inventoried.
  6. The three categories above are released. Everything else is resealed in the box.

Done properly this is a matter of a week or two, and it is one of the cheapest proceedings in the Surrogate's Court.

Is there a quicker route for burial information?

Yes, and it is worth knowing because it needs no petition at all.

Subdivision 2 of section 2003 lets a joint lessee of the box, or an authorised deputy, examine and copy papers relating to the decedent's burial wishes, a cemetery plot deed, or burial society membership. That happens under the supervision of a bank officer.

The originals are not removed. They are copied, resealed in the box, and the officer files a certification with the Surrogate's Court.

So where the urgent need is funeral instructions rather than the will, and there is a joint lessee or deputy on the box, that may be all that is required.

How do I actually collect what is in the box?

By being appointed. There is no shortcut.

That means a petition for Letters Testamentary where there is a will, or Letters of Administration where there is not. Once the court issues letters, the executor or administrator can collect the contents of the box and distribute them under the will or under the rules of intestacy (dying without a will).

The two proceedings are separate and they serve different purposes. Section 2003 gets you the documents. A full appointment gets you the assets. Families often expect the first to do the work of the second, and it does not.

Where the whole estate is modest, the appointment may be simpler than expected — an estate of $50,000 or less in personal property with no real property can go through voluntary administration, which costs a dollar to file.

What if the will is in the box?

This is the most common reason for a section 2003 petition, and the mechanics are specific.

The will does not come to you. The bank delivers it to the Surrogate's Court, where it is filed. It is then available to be offered for probate in the usual way.

That is deliberate. A will in a box has not been proved, and nobody — including the person who finds it — gets to decide what happens to it. The court takes custody.

Frequently asked questions

I am on the box as a joint lessee. Do I still need a court order?

Usually yes, to open it and remove anything. Banks regularly refuse joint tenants and spouses once they know a lessee has died. The narrow exception is subdivision 2 — copying burial-related papers under a bank officer's supervision.

What does it cost?

The court generally charges $20 for the petition and $6 per box. If the key is lost, drilling the box is a separate cost charged by the bank and it is considerably more.

How long does it take?

The order itself is usually quick. What sets the timetable in practice is finding the key and getting an appointment with the right branch.

Can I take the cash or jewellery out?

No. Only the will, a burial plot deed and an insurance policy payable to a named beneficiary leave the box under a section 2003 order. Everything else is inventoried and resealed.

What if we do not know whether a box exists?

Look for the annual rental charge on bank statements, a small unmarked key among the papers, or correspondence from a branch. The Surrogate's Court generally wants to see that a search has been made before accepting an administration petition that says there was no will.

Does the box have to be in New York?

A New York Surrogate's Court order reaches a box held in New York. A box in another state is governed by that state's procedure, which usually means an ancillary proceeding there.

What happens if there are two wills in the box?

Both go to the clerk of the court. Which one controls is a question for the probate proceeding, not for whoever opened the box.

Where to start

If the box might hold the will, a burial plot deed or an insurance policy, a section 2003 petition is the right first step and it is quick and inexpensive. If what you need is the contents — the cash, the bonds, the jewellery — then the real task is the appointment, and the box petition is only the opening move.

Either way, find out whether anyone has the key before you file. It is the single thing most likely to cost the estate time and money.


If your loved one left behind a safe deposit box which needs to be accessed, contact an estate attorney in Queens or Brooklyn today for a free phone consultation.

Law Offices Of Roman Aminov, 147-17 Union Tpke, Queens, NY 11367, (347) 766-2685

Stay Connected With The Law Offices Of Roman Aminov

avvo

About Us

Attorney Advertising Disclaimer: The legal information presented on this site should NOT be construed to be formal legal advice nor the formation of a lawyer or attorney client relationship. Using the advice provided on this site without consulting an attorney can have disastrous results. Prior results do not guarantee similar outcomes.This web site is not intended to solicit clients for matters outside of the State of NY, although we have relationships with attorneys and law firms in states throughout the United States. Free consultation applies to an initial phone consultation.
logo

Queens Office:

147-17 Union Tpke, Kew Gardens Hills, NY 11367

Brooklyn Office:

1600 Avenue M, 2nd Floor, Brooklyn, NY 11230

Manhattan Office:

260 Madison Ave #204, New York, NY 10016, United States

Law offices Of Roman Aminov